Oh, Boy

Good God Luke Menard what were you thinking? You needed to sing a ballad tonight. Hopefully your pretty boy looks will drag you through, otherwise you're finished.

There you go. David Archuleta knows how to pick them. He sounded great. I'm not sure why the judges were so critical of him. Ragged's gag reflex was activated at the sickeningly sweet comments.

Danny Noriega tipped the scale. Ragged hated his Tainted Love but I didn't think it was completely horrible. He's being voted for by AI haters because he's the worst, so I can see him going on through. He's entertaining if nothing else.

David Hernandez started out good but he lost it there in the end. I still think he's one of the best, the gay stripper controversy aside.

Michael Johns was so-so. He seems like he's singing outside his vocal range. It sounds like he's straining and screaming. I think Simon was right. If he finds the right song, he'll really take off. He is Ragged's pick.

David Cook was very good. I like when pop songs are made into rock ones. I think he'll breeze into the next round.

This the closest I came to liking Jason Castro and I still didn't like him. He has to go this week. I'm sorry, but he has to.

Go Chekezie. Way to go to the top of the heap. I hope it's enough to get you through to the next round.

Top 3: David Archuleta, Chekezie, and David Cook

Bottom 3: Danny Noriega, Jason Castro, and Luke Menard

Who should go: Luke Menard and Jason Castro

Who will go: Luke Menard and Chekezie