You Can't Do That

I hate it when I don’t particularly like the genre of music and tonight was one of those nights. That said, I’m still going to give my biased opinion.

Syesha Mercado sounded really good. The song was kind of flat though.

What was Chekezie trying to prove? He was fun but I’m not sure he was that good. The judges liked him though.

Ramiele Mulabay was great. I had a psychic flash that she might win this competition. The judges kind of slammed her though. I don’t get it.

Jason Castro was horrible. Please let him go home.

Carly Smithson sounded fantastic. I kind of still don’t like her though. She had the best song.

David Cook did a very nice job. I really enjoyed his performance. Love the rock thing. I hope he doesn't have the same fate as Chris Daughtry.

Why does Brooke White seem familiar to me. Her look and her voice sounds so familiar. I kind of liked her performance. She hasn't been a favorite but she is good. She was barefooted, too.

David Hernandez did an alright job. He has a blight on him, however. I wouldn't be surprised to see him in the bottom three and perhaps eliminated.

Amanda Overmyer was okay but she is still the worst one. We could lose her and I would be okay.

Michael Johns did a very good job. I enjoyed his song immensely. Superb.

I'm sorry Kristy Lee Cook. Countryfying a Lennon-McCartney song was not a good idea. Ragged said she's glad Kristy won't be singing eight days a week.

Oh, no. David Archuleta forgot the words and he never got the song back. People who forget the words get eliminated. Could the golden boy go?

Top 3: Carly Smithson, David Cook, and Ramiele Mulabay

Bottom 3: Jason Castro, Amanda Overmyer, and Kristy Lee Cook

Who should go: Amanda Overmyer

Who will go: Kristy Lee Cook